Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tanya Coelho's avatar

I know you probably don’t mean it to read like this but I wonder if putting sci-fi and fantasy in a parargraph where you say no racism, sexism, etc and no AI and then go on to say that you “will only accept what contributes to human flourishing” is the right thing to do. The way it’s worded makes it sound like you consider these genres to have no intrinsic value and in fact to be detrimental to human development.

As a reader of a wide variety of literary fiction - including some fantasy and sci-fi - I find the wording of this to be a bit offensive. I’m sure the writers of these genres would feel the same.

Maybe this paragraph can be reworded for greater clarity? Maybe it could be two separate paragraphs so they’re not lumped together with the other things?

Or maybe you do indeed consider those valuable genres to be degenerate in that snobby and messed up way so many literary establishments do. I hope it’s not this. Not very “luminous” if it is. I hope it’s just an accidental oversight.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?